For almost 30 years, buying fish on East 17th Street meant Santa Monica Seafood. Then, in February 2025, the market and cafe on the corridor just over the Newport Heights line closed. By late October 2026, Bear Flag Fish Co. had opened in the same space at 154 E. 17th St., Costa Mesa. The new counter carries more than 20 varieties in the case, a sushi bar with omakase and a full bar, all under one roof.
That return is the headline for anyone who uses 17th Street as a weeknight errand run. It also fits a larger shift on the strip. Two restaurant vacancies on East 17th are being filled by Orange County businesses with deep local roots, one founded by a fisherman and one by a chef whose family still runs it.
Why the old counter closed
Santa Monica Seafood is a seafood distributor first. When it closed the Costa Mesa restaurant and fish market, CEO Roger O'Brien told SeafoodSource that the fish market and cafe was an "insignificant part of our business." He cited an "unsustainable business environment" for California restaurants, including high commercial lease rates and much higher costs for operations, labor and food.
The company's goodbye, posted to Facebook on February 19, 2025 and quoted by SeafoodSource, pointed Costa Mesa customers to the company's Santa Monica store:
"For almost 30 years, we've served Costa Mesa. As we close our doors at this location, our hearts are filled with gratitude for your support throughout the years. This isn't goodbye; it's see you soon. We'd love to welcome you at our Santa Monica location."
For a distributor, the counter was a small side business carrying California lease and labor costs. The space has now gone to a company whose business is built around the counter.
A fish market whose whole business is the counter
According to Greer's OC, fisherman Thomas "Thos" Carson founded Bear Flag Fish Co., and the company is marking two decades in business. The Costa Mesa store is its fourth location. The others are two in Newport Beach, one of them at Crystal Cove, and one in Huntington Beach. Costa Mesa is also Bear Flag's first stand-alone building, and Greer's OC calls it the brand's most elevated location so far.
Greer's OC describes the menu as part fish market, part taco shop and part sushi bar:
| Part of the menu | What it serves |
|---|---|
| Market case | More than 20 varieties, from halibut, swordfish and white sea bass to uni, plus Chilean sea bass, black cod and toro |
| Taco and plate counter | The Bear Flag taco and burrito with panko-crusted white fish, poke bowls, ceviche, seafood salads by the pound, grilled seafood sandwiches and a lobster roll |
| Starters and soups | Shrimp cocktail, calamari fries, sautéed clams and mussels, chowder, cioppino and miso soup |
| Sushi bar | Nigiri, sashimi, signature rolls including the Bear Flag roll with Cajun seared tuna, and an omakase |
| Bar | A full bar serving indoor, counter and patio seating |
Greer's OC also reports that the company plans to add menu items found only at this location. Bear Flag ties sustainability to its own future, saying that protecting the fish supply is good for both the environment and the company.
The look will be familiar from the Newport Beach stores. Steve Jones, founder of the design firm bettershelter, has designed the interior of every Bear Flag. He gives each one its own version of the brand's classic nautical style with a playful, retro twist.
How the hours work for a weeknight
Bear Flag Costa Mesa is open 11 a.m. to 9 p.m., and the phone number is 949-396-2800. Because the market and the dining room share those hours, one stop can cover two different plans. You can pick up a piece of black cod or halibut from the case to cook at home, or sit on the patio with a lobster roll and a drink. OC Foodies describes the setup the same way, as a seafood market with counter service, a sushi bar, a full bar, and indoor and patio seating.
With toro and uni in the market case and an omakase at the sushi bar, a fish counter and a sushi seat now share one address on 17th Street.
Further east, a Tustin family takes the Playa Mesa space
The second vacancy on the strip opened over the summer. Playa Mesa closed after eight years at 428 E. 17th St., and its owners announced the closure on August 1, 2026. "Playa Mesa has officially closed its doors," the restaurant wrote on Instagram, as reported by the Orange County Register. "From the bottom of our hearts, thank you for every meal, every celebration, and every memory."
Less than four weeks later, Zov's announced the space as its fifth Orange County location. The Orange County Business Journal reported a target opening of late 2026. Chef Zov Karamardian founded the restaurant in 1987, and three generations of her family now run it. Its other locations are in Tustin, Irvine, Newport Coast and San Clemente, and the San Clemente restaurant opened earlier this year.
CEO Armen Karamardian told OC Foodies that the neighborhood shares what the family values most, "a genuine love of good food and of gathering around the table." He added, "Everything we serve traces back to my mother's kitchen."
The preview menu OC Foodies published in August includes these dishes:
- House-made hummus, baba ghanoush and freshly baked flatbreads
- Herb-crusted lamb chops, charred skewers and sustainably sourced seafood
- Handcrafted pastas and market-driven salads made for sharing
- Craft cocktails with fresh citrus and garden herbs, and a wine list that pairs coastal California bottles with Old World Mediterranean imports
OC Foodies describes the plan for both weeknight mezze on the patio and milestone dinners. In October, Zov's advertised a Costa Mesa job fair on the 14th, 17th, 21st and 24th, hiring hosts, bussers, servers, bartenders, cooks, dishwashers and managers. The restaurant's Costa Mesa page lists the address as 428 E 17th St., Costa Mesa, CA 92627.
Locals who drive to Tustin for Zov's should know that the "17th" in that restaurant's news is a different street. The flagship sits at the Enderle Center in Tustin, which is being razed and rebranded as Campo on 17th. The Tustin restaurant will stay open during construction. The Costa Mesa location is on East 17th Street, near Newport Heights.
A bakery between the two
The third address in this set is 299 E. 17th St., between Bear Flag and the Zov's space. Sourdough & Co. lists a Costa Mesa location there on its website and says it will accept job applications for that store.
The strip, west to east
| Address | What was there | Who is moving in |
|---|---|---|
| 154 E. 17th St. | Santa Monica Seafood, almost 30 years, closed February 2025 | Bear Flag Fish Co., open 11 a.m. to 9 p.m. |
| 299 E. 17th St. | Sourdough & Co., listed as coming soon | |
| 428 E. 17th St. | Playa Mesa, eight years, closed August 2026 | Zov's, fifth Orange County location, announced for late 2026 |
Both restaurant spaces on this stretch went to Orange County companies. Bear Flag was started by a fisherman and is marking two decades in business. Chef Zov Karamardian founded Zov's in 1987, and three generations of her family run it today. Santa Monica Seafood blamed lease rates and labor costs when it left. The businesses moving in are betting on the same street with full-service formats: a market, a sushi bar and a full bar in one building, and a Mediterranean dining room planned for patio mezze and milestone dinners.
For more on the walks and small spots closer to home, see our Newport Heights neighborhood guide and the Newport Heights loop above Mariner's Mile. Our Eastside Costa Mesa page covers the other side of the street.
A fish counter, an omakase seat and a family Mediterranean dining room within reach of the Heights all affect how a house up the hill fits into everyday life. If you're curious what that's worth for your own place, bouHAUS can put a current value on your Newport Heights home, with design-minded advice from people who shop the same strip.